Season 1998 ELCA DIV 1
5 Pentland H 1 6 Wand Drag 3
1845 Morrison Ian C 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
1790 Davies Gordon H 1 - 0 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1755 Heavens Alan F 1 - 0 Platts William G C 1590
1720 Begg David 1 - 0 Forbes Alistair 1575
1635 Ramsay James Roy 1 - 0 Coulstock Richard J 1575
1600 Ewington Lenny C 1 - 0 Pirrie Gregor 1405
5 - 1
1 Civil Serv 2 2 Wester Hail1
1565 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Hinton Peter 1735
1545 Brown Gerry 0 - 1 Sime David 1665
1540 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Good Stewart A S 1660
1525 Bate Simon 1 - 0 Swanson Bryan 1510
1525 Heatlie Douglas S 0 - 1 Hynd William 1400
1265 MacCrae John 0 - 1 MacKinney Stuart 1375
3 - 3
3 Bank Scot 1 4 Edinburgh 2
1725 Stewart David 0 - 1 Reid Graeme 1700
1505 Russell Graeme R 0 - 1 Aitchison A Keith 1695
1395 Gillespie Edward 0 - 1 Marr John 1700
1390 Findlay Angus J ½ - ½ Montgomery David C 1675
1360 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Stuart Duncan 1615
1280 Colledge John B 0 - 1 Balmer Stephen 0
½ - 5½
7 Edinburgh 3 8 Balerno
1615 Stuart Duncan 0 - 1 Smith Eric P 1780
1610 Girvan Alastair 0 - 1 Angus A Ross 1655
1595 Mountford Alan 1 - 0 Watt David B 1245
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 1 - 0 Bond David E 1240
1405 Havard Leonard 1 - 0 Bond Douglas J 1140
0 Balmer Stephen ½ - ½ Muneer Kashif 0
3½ - 2½
9 Civil Serv 1 11 Livingston 1
1890 Kellett Simon C ½ - ½ Gordon James K 1535
1820 Melville Alan G 1 - 0 Thomson George 1425
1795 Prince Alan R 0 - 1 MacCord Robert 1380
1755 Anderson Neil J ½ - ½ Wright Andrew 1285
1625 MacDonald Gordon J 1 - 0 MacGilvary David 0
1565 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Davis Anton 0
4 - 2
10 Musselburgh2 12 Wand Drag 2
1610 Capaldi Alex 0 - 1 Wallace David 1870
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1485 Barron Vince 0 - 1 Sloan S Elliot 1875
1460 Loudon James M 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
1445 Martin David B 0 - 1 Shapland David 1420
1415 Semkiw Ivan 0 - 1 Laurie Stephen D 0
0 - 6
1 Civil Serv 2 10 Musselburgh2
1665 Austin Rudolf J 0 - 1 Capaldi Alex 1610
1565 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Anderson Dennis R B 1550
1545 Brown Gerry ½ - ½ Barron Vince 1485
1540 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Loudon James M 1460
1525 Bate Simon 1 - 0 Martin David B 1445
1525 Heatlie Douglas S 1 - 0 Semkiw Ivan 1415
4½ - 1½
6 Wand Drag 3 12 Wand Drag 2
1740 Tate Alan 1 - 0 Campbell Eoin S 1895
1625 Oswald Gerrard 1 - 0 Wallace David 1870
1590 Platts William G C 0 - 1 Sloan S Elliot 1875
1575 Coulstock Richard J 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1575 Forbes Alistair ½ - ½ Vangelov Peter 1810
1490 Doris Peter J 1 - 0 Laurie Stephen D 0
3½ - 2½
11 Livingston 1 2 Wester Hail1
1535 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Hinton Peter 1735
1500 Petch Rab 0 - 1 Good Stewart A S 1660
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Swanson Bryan 1510
1380 MacCord Robert ½ - ½ MacKinnon Neil F 1490
1285 Wright Andrew 0 - 1 Williamson Keith 1400
0 MacGilvary David 1 - 0 MacKinney Stuart 1375
1½ - 4½
9 Civil Serv 1 8 Balerno
1890 Kellett Simon C 1 - 0 Angus A Ross 1655
1820 Melville Alan G 1 - 0 Bassett Paul G 1475
1815 Greensmith David 1 - 0 MacKay Iain 1440
1795 Prince Alan R 1 - 0 Goldie Peter 1390
1625 MacDonald Gordon J 1 - 0 Watt David B 1245
1610 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Bond David E 1240
6 - 0
4 Edinburgh 2 5 Pentland H 1
1975 Paige Roger ½ - ½ Morrison Ian C 1845
1770 Rutherford Elaine 1 - 0 Davies Gordon H 1790
1695 Aitchison A Keith ½ - ½ Heavens Alan F 1755
1675 Montgomery David C 1 - 0 Ramsay James Roy 1635
1615 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Ewington Lenny C 1600
0 Spil Jara 0 - 1 Kilgour James W 1515
4 - 2
3 Bank Scot 1 7 Edinburgh 3
1725 Stewart David 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1615
1635 MacMillan Peter ½ - ½ Girvan Alastair 1610
1505 Russell Graeme R 0 - 1 Mountford Alan 1595
1440 MacKay Iain J 1 - 0 MacLafferty Brydon G 1550
1395 Gillespie Edward 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1405
1390 Findlay Angus J 0 - 1 Graham James 0
3½ - 2½
11 Livingston 1 6 Wand Drag 3
1535 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
1500 Petch Rab 0 - 1 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1425 Thomson George 1 - 0 Coulstock Richard J 1575
1400 Wright Paul 1 - 0 Doris Peter J 1490
1380 MacCord Robert 0 - 1 Forbes Alistair 1575
0 MacGilvary David 1 - 0 Hepburn James 1420
3 - 3
8 Balerno 10 Musselburgh2
1780 Smith Eric P 0 - 1 Stevens Ian 1695
1655 Angus A Ross 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1475 Bassett Paul G ½ - ½ Anderson Dennis R B 1550
1390 Goldie Peter ½ - ½ Barron Vince 1485
1245 Watt David B 1 - 0 Loudon James M 1460
1240 Bond David E 1 - 0 Martin David B 1445
4 - 2
12 Wand Drag 2 1 Civil Serv 2
1875 Konarski Jannic 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1875 Sloan S Elliot 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1565
1880 Heron Donald ½ - ½ Brown Gerry 1545
1895 Campbell Eoin S 1 - 0 Anderson George C 1540
1870 Wallace David 1 - 0 Bate Simon 1525
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
4½ - 1½
2 Wester Hail1 3 Bank Scot 1
1665 Sime David 0 - 1 Stewart David 1725
1660 Good Stewart A S 1 - 0 MacKay Iain J 1440
1510 Swanson Bryan 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1405
1490 MacKinnon Neil F 1 - 0 Gillespie Edward 1395
1375 MacKinney Stuart 1 - 0 Findlay Angus J 1390
1275 Robertson Kevin H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
5 - 1
7 Edinburgh 3 5 Pentland H 1
1615 Stuart Duncan 0 - 1 Morrison Ian C 1845
1610 Girvan Alastair 1 - 0 Davies Gordon H 1790
1595 Mountford Alan 0 - 1 Heavens Alan F 1755
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G ½ - ½ Begg David 1720
1405 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 Ramsay James Roy 1635
0 Graham James 1 - 0 Ewington Lenny C 1600
2½ - 3½
2 Wester Hail1 4 Edinburgh 2
1735 Hinton Peter 1 - 0 Morrison Lynne G P 1765
1665 Sime David 1 - 0 Marshall William A 1760
1660 Good Stewart A S 0 - 1 Reid Graeme 1700
1510 Swanson Bryan 0 - 1 Marr John 1700
1490 MacKinnon Neil F 1 - 0 Aitchison A Keith 1695
1375 MacKinney Stuart ½ - ½ Montgomery David C 1675
3½ - 2½
4 Edinburgh 2 9 Civil Serv 1
1975 Paige Roger 1 - 0 Kellett Simon C 1890
1770 Rutherford Elaine 1 - 0 Melville Alan G 1820
1760 Marshall William A 1 - 0 Greensmith David 1815
1700 Marr John 1 - 0 Prince Alan R 1795
1695 Aitchison A Keith 0 - 1 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
1675 Montgomery David C 1 - 0 Miller Patrick M 1610
5 - 1
8 Balerno 6 Wand Drag 3
1780 Smith Eric P 1 - 0 Tate Alan 1740
1655 Angus A Ross 1 - 0 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1475 Bassett Paul G ½ - ½ Platts William G C 1590
1245 Watt David B ½ - ½ Forbes Alistair 1575
1240 Bond David E 1 - 0 Hepburn James 1420
1140 Bond Douglas J H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
5 - 1
10 Musselburgh2 3 Bank Scot 1
1945 Fraser Mark G 1 - 0 Stewart David 1725
1695 Stevens Ian 0 - 1 MacMillan Peter 1635
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 0 - 1 Russell Graeme R 1505
1610 Capaldi Alex 1 - 0 MacKay Iain J 1440
1535 Small Alastair M 1 - 0 Gillespie Edward 1395
1485 Barron Vince 1 - 0 Findlay Angus J 1390
4 - 2
5 Pentland H 1 1 Civil Serv 2
1845 Morrison Ian C 1 - 0 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1755 Heavens Alan F 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1565
1600 Ewington Lenny C ½ - ½ Brown Gerry 1545
1465 Ridland Lindsay S 0 - 1 Anderson George C 1540
1435 Purkins Terry E ½ - ½ Bate Simon 1525
1375 Fenoulhet Ray G 1 - 0 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
4 - 2
12 Wand Drag 2 11 Livingston 1
1875 Konarski Jannic 1 - 0 Gordon James K 1535
1875 Sloan S Elliot 1 - 0 Petch Rab 1500
1880 Heron Donald 1 - 0 Thomson George 1425
1895 Campbell Eoin S 1 - 0 MacCord Robert 1380
1870 Wallace David 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 MacGilvary David 0
6 - 0
7 Edinburgh 3 9 Civil Serv 1
1615 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Kellett Simon C 1890
1610 Girvan Alastair 1 - 0 Melville Alan G 1820
1595 Mountford Alan 0 - 1 Greensmith David 1815
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 0 - 1 Prince Alan R 1795
1405 Havard Leonard 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
0 Balmer Stephen ½ - ½ Miller Patrick M 1610
3½ - 2½
8 Balerno 3 Bank Scot 1
1780 Smith Eric P 0 - 1 Stewart David 1725
1680 Johnstone David ½ - ½ MacKay Iain J 1440
1655 Angus A Ross 0 - 1 Kostryckyj Michael 1410
1475 Bassett Paul G 0 - 1 Gillespie Edward 1395
1245 Watt David B 1 - 0 Findlay Angus J 1390
1240 Bond David E 0 - 1 Gray Ian 0
1½ - 4½
10 Musselburgh2 5 Pentland H 1
1695 Stevens Ian A - H Morrison Ian C 1845 Away Win by Default
1610 Capaldi Alex 0 - 1 Heavens Alan F 1755
1535 Small Alastair M ½ - ½ Begg David 1720
1485 Barron Vince 0 - 1 Ramsay James Roy 1635
1210 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Ewington Lenny C 1600
1135 Stokes Eddie H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
2½ - 3½
4 Edinburgh 2 11 Livingston 1
1975 Paige Roger 1 - 0 Gordon James K 1535
1760 Marshall William A 1 - 0 Petch Rab 1500
1700 Reid Graeme 1 - 0 Thomson George 1425
1700 Marr John 1 - 0 MacCord Robert 1380
1695 Aitchison A Keith 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
0 Balmer Stephen ½ - ½ MacGilvary David 0
5½ - ½
7 Edinburgh 3 1 Civil Serv 2
1615 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1565
1610 Girvan Alastair 1 - 0 Brown Gerry 1545
1595 Mountford Alan ½ - ½ Anderson George C 1540
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 0 - 1 Bate Simon 1525
1405 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
0 Crossman 0 - 1 Jilow Asghar 1470
2½ - 3½
12 Wand Drag 2 9 Civil Serv 1
1875 Konarski Jannic ½ - ½ Melville Alan G 1820
1875 Sloan S Elliot 0 - 1 Greensmith David 1815
1880 Heron Donald 1 - 0 Prince Alan R 1795
1870 Wallace David 1 - 0 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
1660 MacIntosh Alasdair 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1610
3½ - 2½
2 Wester Hail1 6 Wand Drag 3
1665 Sime David ½ - ½ Tate Alan 1740
1660 Good Stewart A S 1 - 0 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1490 MacKinnon Neil F 1 - 0 Platts William G C 1590
1375 MacKinney Stuart 0 - 1 Forbes Alistair 1575
1275 Robertson Kevin 1 - 0 Doris Peter J 1490
1240 Robertson Kenneth A H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
4½ - 1½
8 Balerno 12 Wand Drag 2
1780 Smith Eric P 0 - 1 Sloan S Elliot 1875
1655 Angus A Ross 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1475 Bassett Paul G 0 - 1 Wallace David 1870
1245 Watt David B 0 - 1 Heron Donald 1880
1240 Bond David E 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
0 Muneer Kashif 0 - 1 Porter William 1495
0 - 6
7 Edinburgh 3 2 Wester Hail1
1615 Stuart Duncan 0 - 1 Hinton Peter 1735
1610 Girvan Alastair 0 - 1 Sime David 1665
1595 Mountford Alan ½ - ½ Good Stewart A S 1660
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 0 - 1 MacKinnon Neil F 1490
1405 Havard Leonard ½ - ½ MacKinney Stuart 1375
0 Fawcett N 1 - 0 Henderson Malcolm 1345
2 - 4
5 Pentland H 1 9 Civil Serv 1
1845 Morrison Ian C 0 - 1 Kellett Simon C 1890
1755 Heavens Alan F H - A Melville Alan G 1820 Home Win by Default
1720 Begg David ½ - ½ Greensmith David 1815
1635 Ramsay James Roy 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
1515 Kilgour James W 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1610
1410 Wallace Jim 1 - 0 MacCrae John 1265
3½ - 2½
1 Civil Serv 2 11 Livingston 1
1665 Austin Rudolf J ½ - ½ Gordon James K 1535
1540 Anderson George C 0 - 1 Petch Rab 1500
1545 Brown Gerry 1 - 0 Thomson George 1425
1525 Bate Simon 1 - 0 MacCord Robert 1380
1525 Heatlie Douglas S 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1200 Bridgeman Graham ½ - ½ MacGilvary David 0
4 - 2
10 Musselburgh2 4 Edinburgh 2
1610 Capaldi Alex 0 - 1 Rutherford Elaine 1770
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 0 - 1 Marshall William A 1760
1535 Small Alastair M 0 - 1 Reid Graeme 1700
1485 Barron Vince 0 - 1 Marr John 1700
1445 Martin David B ½ - ½ Aitchison A Keith 1695
Not Given A - H Jones Robert M 1175 Away Win by Default
½ - 5½
3 Bank Scot 1 6 Wand Drag 3
1725 Stewart David 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
1635 MacMillan Peter 0 - 1 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1505 Russell Graeme R 1 - 0 Platts William G C 1590
1395 Gillespie Edward 1 - 0 Forbes Alistair 1575
0 Gray Ian 1 - 0 Doris Peter J 1490
1390 Findlay Angus J 0 - 1 Hepburn James 1420
3 - 3
11 Livingston 1 8 Balerno
1535 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Smith Eric P 1780
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Johnstone David 1680
1380 MacCord Robert 0 - 1 Angus A Ross 1655
1325 Dunsmore Alan ½ - ½ Bassett Paul G 1475
1285 Wright Andrew 0 - 1 Watt David B 1245
0 MacGilvary David 1 - 0 Bond David E 1240
1½ - 4½
2 Wester Hail1 5 Pentland H 1
1735 Hinton Peter 0 - 1 Morrison Ian C 1845
1665 Sime David ½ - ½ Davies Gordon H 1790
1660 Good Stewart A S 0 - 1 Heavens Alan F 1755
1490 MacKinnon Neil F 0 - 1 Ramsay James Roy 1635
1375 MacKinney Stuart 1 - 0 Ridland Lindsay S 1465
1320 Tait Chris T ½ - ½ Wallace Jim 1410
2 - 4
3 Bank Scot 1 1 Civil Serv 2
1725 Stewart David 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1635 MacMillan Peter 0 - 1 Brown Gerry 1545
1505 Russell Graeme R 0 - 1 Anderson George C 1540
1440 MacKay Iain J 0 - 1 Bate Simon 1525
1395 Gillespie Edward 0 - 1 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
1390 Findlay Angus J 0 - 1 Pannell John 0
0 - 6
9 Civil Serv 1 10 Musselburgh2
1890 Kellett Simon C 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1820 Melville Alan G ½ - ½ Anderson Dennis R B 1550
1815 Greensmith David ½ - ½ Small Alastair M 1535
1625 MacDonald Gordon J 0 - 1 Barron Vince 1485
1610 Miller Patrick M ½ - ½ Martin David B 1445
1545 Brown Gerry 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1210
2½ - 3½
6 Wand Drag 3 7 Edinburgh 3
1740 Tate Alan 0 - 1 Stuart Duncan 1615
1625 Oswald Gerrard 0 - 1 Girvan Alastair 1610
1590 Platts William G C ½ - ½ Mountford Alan 1595
1575 Forbes Alistair 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1405
1495 Porter William ½ - ½ Fawcett N 0
1490 Doris Peter J 0 - 1 Balmer Stephen 0
2 - 4
4 Edinburgh 2 12 Wand Drag 2
1975 Paige Roger 0 - 1 MacLay John W 2040
1760 Marshall William A ½ - ½ Konarski Jannic 1875
1700 Reid Graeme 0 - 1 Sloan S Elliot 1875
1700 Marr John 0 - 1 Heron Donald 1880
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G ½ - ½ Campbell Eoin S 1895
1405 Havard Leonard ½ - ½ Vangelov Peter 1810
1½ - 4½
5 Pentland H 1 3 Bank Scot 1
1845 Morrison Ian C 1 - 0 Stewart David 1725
1790 Davies Gordon H 1 - 0 Russell Graeme R 1505
1755 Heavens Alan F 0 - 1 MacKay Iain J 1440
1635 Ramsay James Roy 1 - 0 Gillespie Edward 1395
1600 Ewington Lenny C 1 - 0 Gray Ian 0
1435 Purkins Terry E 1 - 0 Findlay Angus J 1390
5 - 1
1 Civil Serv 2 9 Civil Serv 1
1665 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Kellett Simon C 1890
1565 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Melville Alan G 1820
1545 Brown Gerry ½ - ½ Greensmith David 1815
1540 Anderson George C ½ - ½ Prince Alan R 1795
1525 Heatlie Douglas S 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
1525 Bate Simon 1 - 0 Miller Patrick M 1610
5 - 1
8 Balerno 4 Edinburgh 2
1780 Smith Eric P ½ - ½ Rutherford Elaine 1770
1475 Bassett Paul G 0 - 1 Morrison Lynne G P 1765
1245 Watt David B 0 - 1 Marshall William A 1760
1390 Goldie Peter 0 - 1 Montgomery David C 1675
1240 Bond David E 0 - 1 Fawcett N 0
1140 Bond Douglas J 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1405
1½ - 4½
12 Wand Drag 2 2 Wester Hail1
2065 Minnican Alan W 1 - 0 Hinton Peter 1735
1875 Sloan S Elliot ½ - ½ Sime David 1665
1875 Konarski Jannic ½ - ½ Good Stewart A S 1660
1880 Heron Donald ½ - ½ MacKinnon Neil F 1490
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 Hynd William 1400
1495 Porter William 0 - 1 MacKinney Stuart 1375
3½ - 2½
7 Edinburgh 3 11 Livingston 1
1610 Girvan Alastair ½ - ½ Gordon James K 1535
1595 Mountford Alan ½ - ½ Petch Rab 1500
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 1 - 0 Thomson George 1425
1405 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 MacCord Robert 1380
0 Balmer Stephen 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
0 Crossman 0 - 1 MacGilvary David 0
3 - 3
10 Musselburgh2 6 Wand Drag 3
1945 Fraser Mark G 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
1610 Capaldi Alex 1 - 0 Oswald Gerrard 1625
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 0 - 1 Platts William G C 1590
1535 Small Alastair M ½ - ½ Forbes Alistair 1575
1485 Barron Vince 1 - 0 Coulstock Richard J 1575
1445 Martin David B V - V Hepburn James 1420 Void/Double Default
2½ - 2½
6 Wand Drag 3 1 Civil Serv 2
1740 Tate Alan 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1625 Oswald Gerrard 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1565
1590 Platts William G C 0 - 1 Brown Gerry 1545
1575 Coulstock Richard J ½ - ½ Anderson George C 1540
1575 Forbes Alistair 1 - 0 Bate Simon 1525
1420 Hepburn James A - H Heatlie Douglas S 1525 Away Win by Default
2½ - 3½
2 Wester Hail1 8 Balerno
1665 Sime David ½ - ½ Smith Eric P 1780
1735 Hinton Peter 0 - 1 Johnstone David 1680
1660 Good Stewart A S 1 - 0 Bassett Paul G 1475
1490 MacKinnon Neil F ½ - ½ Watt David B 1245
1375 MacKinney Stuart 0 - 1 Bond David E 1240
1275 Robertson Kevin ½ - ½ Muneer Kashif 0
2½ - 3½
12 Wand Drag 2 5 Pentland H 1
2040 MacLay John W 1 - 0 Morrison Ian C 1845
1875 Sloan S Elliot 1 - 0 Davies Gordon H 1790
1875 Konarski Jannic ½ - ½ Heavens Alan F 1755
1870 Wallace David 0 - 1 Begg David 1720
1880 Heron Donald ½ - ½ Ramsay James Roy 1635
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 Ewington Lenny C 1600
4 - 2
4 Edinburgh 2 7 Edinburgh 3
1770 Rutherford Elaine 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1615
1700 Marr John 0 - 1 Mountford Alan 1595
1695 Aitchison A Keith 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1405
1550 MacLafferty Brydon G 0 - 1 Balmer Stephen 0
0 Sykes Chris 1 - 0 Cubitt David 1385
Not Given V - V Not Given Void/Double Default
3 - 2
9 Civil Serv 1 3 Bank Scot 1
1890 Kellett Simon C 1 - 0 Stewart David 1725
1820 Melville Alan G 1 - 0 MacMillan Peter 1635
1795 Prince Alan R 1 - 0 Russell Graeme R 1505
1665 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 MacKay Iain J 1440
1625 MacDonald Gordon J 0 - 1 Gillespie Edward 1395
1610 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Findlay Angus J 1390
5 - 1
11 Livingston 1 10 Musselburgh2
1535 Gordon James K 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1500 Petch Rab ½ - ½ Anderson Dennis R B 1550
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Small Alastair M 1535
1380 MacCord Robert 0 - 1 Barron Vince 1485
0 MacGilvary David 0 - 1 Loudon James M 1460
1285 Wright Andrew 1 - 0 Martin David B 1445
2½ - 3½
8 Balerno 5 Pentland H 1
1780 Smith Eric P 0 - 1 Morrison Ian C 1845
1680 Johnstone David A - H Heavens Alan F 1755 Away Win by Default
1655 Angus A Ross 0 - 1 Begg David 1720
1245 Watt David B 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1600
1240 Bond David E 0 - 1 Ewington Bryan 1430
0 Muneer Kashif 1 - 0 MacFarlane George C 940
1 - 5
11 Livingston 1 3 Bank Scot 1
1535 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Stewart David 1725
1500 Petch Rab 1 - 0 MacMillan Peter 1635
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 MacKay Iain J 1440
1380 MacCord Robert 1 - 0 Gray Ian 0
0 MacGilvary David 0 - 1 Gillespie Edward 1395
1285 Wright Andrew 0 - 1 Findlay Angus J 1390
2 - 4
12 Wand Drag 2 7 Edinburgh 3
1875 Konarski Jannic 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1615
1875 Sloan S Elliot 1 - 0 MacGregor Lindsay A 1575
1895 Campbell Eoin S 1 - 0 Fawcett N 0
1870 Wallace David 1 - 0 MacLafferty Brydon G 1550
1880 Heron Donald 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1405
1810 Vangelov Peter 1 - 0 Sykes Chris 0
6 - 0
2 Wester Hail1 10 Musselburgh2
1665 Sime David 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1660 Good Stewart A S 1 - 0 Anderson Dennis R B 1550
1490 MacKinnon Neil F 0 - 1 Small Alastair M 1535
1400 Williamson Keith ½ - ½ Barron Vince 1485
1375 MacKinney Stuart ½ - ½ Loudon James M 1460
1225 Girdwood Paul 1 - 0 Martin David B 1445
4 - 2
4 Edinburgh 2 1 Civil Serv 2
1770 Rutherford Elaine 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1565
1760 Marshall William A 1 - 0 Brown Gerry 1545
1700 Reid Graeme ½ - ½ Bate Simon 1525
1700 Marr John 1 - 0 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
1695 Aitchison A Keith 1 - 0 Jilow Asghar 1470
1675 Montgomery David C 1 - 0 Pannell John 0
5½ - ½
6 Wand Drag 3 9 Civil Serv 1
1625 Oswald Gerrard 0 - 1 Kellett Simon C 1890
1590 Platts William G C 0 - 1 Melville Alan G 1820
1575 Coulstock Richard J 0 - 1 Greensmith David 1815
1575 Forbes Alistair 0 - 1 Prince Alan R 1795
1490 Doris Peter J 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
0 Carmichael J 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1610
1 - 5
3 Bank Scot 1 12 Wand Drag 2
1725 Stewart David 0 - 1 Sloan S Elliot 1875
1505 Russell Graeme R 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1440 MacKay Iain J 0 - 1 Campbell Eoin S 1895
0 Gray Ian 1 - 0 Heron Donald 1880
1395 Gillespie Edward 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
1390 Findlay Angus J 1 - 0 Doris Peter J 1490
2 - 4
1 Civil Serv 2 8 Balerno
1665 Austin Rudolf J 0 - 1 Smith Eric P 1780
1565 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Johnstone David 1680
1545 Brown Gerry 0 - 1 Angus A Ross 1655
1540 Anderson George C ½ - ½ Bassett Paul G 1475
1525 Bate Simon 1 - 0 Watt David B 1245
1525 Heatlie Douglas S ½ - ½ Bond David E 1240
3 - 3
6 Wand Drag 3 4 Edinburgh 2
1625 Oswald Gerrard 0 - 1 Marshall William A 1760
1590 Platts William G C 1 - 0 Marr John 1700
1575 Forbes Alistair 1 - 0 Aitchison A Keith 1695
1490 Doris Peter J 0 - 1 Sykes Chris 0
1420 Hepburn James 0 - 1 Crossman 0
0 Carmichael J 0 - 1 Jones Robert M 1175
2 - 4
9 Civil Serv 1 2 Wester Hail1
1890 Kellett Simon C 0 - 1 Sime David 1665
1820 Melville Alan G 0 - 1 Hinton Peter 1735
1815 Greensmith David 1 - 0 Good Stewart A S 1660
1795 Prince Alan R 1 - 0 Swanson Bryan 1510
1665 Austin Rudolf J ½ - ½ MacKinnon Neil F 1490
1610 Miller Patrick M ½ - ½ MacKinney Stuart 1375
3 - 3
10 Musselburgh2 7 Edinburgh 3
1945 Fraser Mark G 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1615
1610 Capaldi Alex ½ - ½ Girvan Alastair 1610
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 1 - 0 Mountford Alan 1595
1535 Small Alastair M 1 - 0 MacLafferty Brydon G 1550
1485 Barron Vince 0 - 1 Balmer Stephen 0
1445 Martin David B 0 - 1 Sykes Chris 0
3½ - 2½
5 Pentland H 1 11 Livingston 1
1790 Davies Gordon H 1 - 0 Gordon James K 1535
1755 Heavens Alan F 1 - 0 MacCord Robert 1380
1720 Begg David ½ - ½ Dunsmore Alan 1325
1635 Ramsay James Roy 1 - 0 Ferguson Don 1290
1600 Ewington Lenny C 1 - 0 Robinson Stuart 1255
1430 Ewington Bryan 0 - 1 MacGilvary David 0
4½ - 1½
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (6 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 12 Wand Drag 2 11 10 1 0 20 45 10 11 0 0 0 50½ 77
2 4 Edinburgh 2 11 9 2 0 18 40 13 11 1 1 0 46½ 70
3 5 Pentland H 1 11 9 2 0 18 33 17 12 3 1 0 42 64
4 2 Wester Hail1 11 6 3 2 14 28 19 17 2 0 0 38½ 58
5 1 Civil Serv 2 11 6 3 2 14 29 23 13 1 0 0 36½ 55
6 9 Civil Serv 1 11 4 6 1 9 29 24 12 0 1 0 35 53
7 8 Balerno 11 4 6 1 9 19 32 13 1 1 0 26½ 40
8 10 Musselburgh2 11 4 6 1 9 18 31 13 1 3 0 25½ 39
9 7 Edinburgh 3 11 3 7 1 7 22 31 12 0 1 0 28 42
10 3 Bank Scot 1 11 3 7 1 7 21 41 3 0 1 0 22½ 34
11 6 Wand Drag 3 11 1 7 3 5 19 35 8 0 4 0 23 35
12 11 Livingston 1 11 0 9 2 2 14 41 11 0 0 0 19½ 30
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 132 59 59 14 132 317 317 136 9 13 0 394
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Pld Pts
1 Civil Serv 2 x 3 6 ½ 2 3½ 3½ 3 5 4½ 4 1½ 66 36½
2 Wester Hail1 3 x 5 3½ 2 4½ 4 2½ 3 4 4½ 2½ 66 38½
3 Bank Scot 1 0 1 x ½ 1 3 3½ 4½ 1 2 4 2 66 22½
4 Edinburgh 2 5½ 2½ 5½ x 4 4 3 4½ 5 5½ 5½ 1½ 66 46½
5 Pentland H 1 4 4 5 2 x 5 3½ 5 3½ 3½ 4½ 2 66 42
6 Wand Drag 3 2½ 1½ 3 2 1 x 2 1 1 2½ 3 3½ 66 23
7 Edinburgh 3 2½ 2 2½ 2 2½ 4 x 3½ 3½ 2½ 3 0 66 28
8 Balerno 3 3½ 1½ 1½ 1 5 2½ x 0 4 4½ 0 66 26½
9 Civil Serv 1 1 3 5 1 2½ 5 2½ 6 x 2½ 4 2½ 66 35
10 Musselburgh2 1½ 2 4 ½ 2½ 2½ 3½ 2 3½ x 3½ 0 66 25½
11 Livingston 1 2 1½ 2 ½ 1½ 3 3 1½ 2 2½ x 0 66 19½
12 Wand Drag 2 4½ 3½ 4 4½ 4 2½ 6 6 3½ 6 6 x 66 50½
*** Team 1 Civil Serv 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
11978 Jackson Ralph 1565 NEW CS 9 4
7921 Brown Gerry 1545 CS 11 5
3046 Anderson George C 1540 CS 10 6
3143 Bate Simon 1525 CS 11 8
4313 Heatlie Douglas S 1525 CSWD 11 6½
8757 MacCrae John 1265 CS 1 0
3084 Austin Rudolf J 1665 EDCS 8 4½
8246 Jilow Asghar 1470 CS 2 1
9033 Bridgeman Graham 1200 CS 1 ½
13076 Pannell John 0 CS 2 1
*** Team 2 Wester Hail1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6612 Hinton Peter 1735 J17 WHBR 8 4
9646 Sime David 1665 J14 WHBR 10 7
4113 Good Stewart A S 1660 WH 11 6
6831 Swanson Bryan 1510 J17 WH 5 2
7709 Hynd William 1400 WH 2 1
5147 MacKinney Stuart 1375 WH 11 6
8924 Williamson Keith 1400 J13 BUWH 2 1½
5148 MacKinnon Neil F 1490 WH 10 6
9293 Robertson Kevin 1275 J12 BU 3 2½
5817 Robertson Kenneth A 1240 WH 1 1
4324 Henderson Malcolm 1345 WH 1 0
7575 Tait Chris T 1320 WH 1 ½
11503 Girdwood Paul 1225 WH 1 1
*** Team 3 Bank Scot 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6117 Stewart David 1725 BS 11 4
8748 Russell Graeme R 1505 BS 8 2
4081 Gillespie Edward 1395 BS 11 5
3917 Findlay Angus J 1390 BS 11 2½
5442 Murray Robin H 1360 BS 1 0
3556 Colledge John B 1280 BS 1 0
7953 MacMillan Peter 1635 BS 6 1½
4786 MacKay Iain J 1440 BS 9 3½
6910 Murray Findlay R 1405 BS 1 0
4622 Kostryckyj Michael 1410 BS 1 1
12416 Gray Ian 0 BS 5 3
*** Team 4 Edinburgh 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
8523 Reid Graeme 1700 EDWH 6 4½
3020 Aitchison A Keith 1695 ED 9 5
4868 Marr John 1700 ED 9 6
10572 Montgomery David C 1675 EDWD 6 5
10514 Stuart Duncan 1615 EDWD 2 2
12548 Balmer Stephen 0 ED 2 1½
7145 Paige Roger 1975 ED 4 2½
6744 Rutherford Elaine 1770 J14 ED 6 5½
13075 Spil Jara 0 ED 1 0
5377 Morrison Lynne G P 1765 EDEU 2 1
6804 Marshall William A 1760 ED 8 6½
4509 Jones Robert M 1175 ED 2 2
5151 MacLafferty Brydon G 1550 EDCH 2 ½
8057 Havard Leonard 1405 ED 2 ½
12977 Fawcett N 0 ED 1 1
12843 Sykes Chris 0 ED 2 2
13074 Crossman 0 ED 1 1
*** Team 5 Pentland H 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5375 Morrison Ian C 1845 PH 10 6½
3688 Davies Gordon H 1790 PHCC 7 3½
4314 Heavens Alan F 1755 PH 11 9
3164 Begg David 1720 PH 7 5
5710 Ramsay James Roy 1635 LSPH 9 7½
3865 Ewington Lenny C 1600 PH 9 4½
7025 Kilgour James W 1515 PHBS 2 1
7097 Ridland Lindsay S 1465 PH 2 0
5689 Purkins Terry E 1435 PH 2 1½
3891 Fenoulhet Ray G 1375 PH 1 1
6354 Wallace Jim 1410 PH 2 1½
3864 Ewington Bryan 1430 J20 PH 2 1
4771 MacFarlane George C 940 STPH 1 0
*** Team 6 Wand Drag 3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6191 Tate Alan 1740 J18 WDBN 9 5½
11412 Oswald Gerrard 1625 SBWD 11 4
5650 Platts William G C 1590 STWD 10 3
8254 Forbes Alistair 1575 SSWD 11 6½
3609 Coulstock Richard J 1575 JPWD 6 ½
5643 Pirrie Gregor 1405 WDBS 1 0
3774 Doris Peter J 1490 SBWD 7 2
9041 Hepburn James 1420 WD 6 1
5666 Porter William 1495 WD 1 ½
13077 Carmichael J 0 WD 2 0
*** Team 7 Edinburgh 3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
10514 Stuart Duncan 1615 EDWD 10 3
4092 Girvan Alastair 1610 CSED 9 5½
8001 Mountford Alan 1595 ED 10 5
5151 MacLafferty Brydon G 1550 EDCH 9 2½
8057 Havard Leonard 1405 ED 10 2½
12548 Balmer Stephen 0 ED 6 5
12440 Graham James 0 ED 2 2
0 0 0 0
12977 Fawcett N 0 ED 3 1½
13074 Crossman 0 ED 2 0
3648 Cubitt David 1385 ED 1 0
5076 MacGregor Lindsay A 1575 EDWD 1 0
12843 Sykes Chris 0 ED 2 1
*** Team 8 Balerno ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6033 Smith Eric P 1780 BN 10 5
3065 Angus A Ross 1655 BN 9 5
6415 Watt David B 1245 BN 11 4
3229 Bond David E 1240 BN 11 3½
3230 Bond Douglas J 1140 J19 BN 3 2
11319 Muneer Kashif 0 J14 BN 4 2
3141 Bassett Paul G 1475 BN 9 2
8000 MacKay Iain 1440 BN 1 0
4108 Goldie Peter 1390 BN 3 ½
7092 Johnstone David 1680 BN 5 2½
*** Team 9 Civil Serv 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4539 Kellett Simon C 1890 CSHC 10 5½
9060 Melville Alan G 1820 CSWD 11 5
10488 Prince Alan R 1795 CS 9 5½
3053 Anderson Neil J 1755 CS 1 ½
4765 MacDonald Gordon J 1625 CS 10 3
11978 Jackson Ralph 1565 NEW CS 1 1
5270 Miller Patrick M 1610 CS 10 6½
7914 Greensmith David 1815 CS 9 6½
3084 Austin Rudolf J 1665 EDCS 3 1½
8757 MacCrae John 1265 CS 1 0
7921 Brown Gerry 1545 CS 1 0
*** Team 10 Musselburgh2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3432 Capaldi Alex 1610 MU 11 3½
3044 Anderson Dennis R B 1550 MU 10 2½
7839 Barron Vince 1485 MU 11 5½
4724 Loudon James M 1460 MU 5 1½
4879 Martin David B 1445 MU 9 1
5935 Semkiw Ivan 1415 MU 2 0
8679 Stevens Ian 1695 J18 MUWD 3 1
3986 Fraser Mark G 1945 MUWD 3 2
6013 Small Alastair M 1535 MU 8 5½
4379 Hope Iain D 1210 MU 2 2
6140 Stokes Eddie 1135 MU 1 1
*** Team 11 Livingston 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4127 Gordon James K 1535 LV 11 2½
10598 Thomson George 1425 LV 10 1
4979 MacCord Robert 1380 LV 11 3½
11834 Wright Andrew 1285 NEW LV 9 1½
12405 MacGilvary David 0 LV 11 6
7544 Davis Anton 0 LVDF 1 0
5621 Petch Rab 1500 LV 8 3
9587 Wright Paul 1400 J18 LVBK 1 1
7464 Dunsmore Alan 1325 LV 2 1
3896 Ferguson Don 1290 LV 1 0
5831 Robinson Stuart 1255 LV 1 0
*** Team 12 Wand Drag 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6346 Wallace David 1870 FAWD 8 6
4621 Konarski Jannic 1875 WD 11 8
6012 Sloan S Elliot 1875 WD 11 9½
7576 Vangelov Peter 1810 EDWD 11 10
12439 Shapland David 1420 EUWD 1 1
4653 Laurie Stephen D 0 WD 2 1
3415 Campbell Eoin S 1895 WD 6 4½
4339 Heron Donald 1880 WDED 9 6½
5093 MacIntosh Alasdair 1660 WHWD 1 0
5666 Porter William 1495 WD 2 1
5168 MacLay John W 2040 GRWD 2 2
5288 Minnican Alan W 2065 PYWD 1 1
3774 Doris Peter J 1490 SBWD 1 0
Edinburgh University League Results 1997/98