Team Results11 EDIN UNIV 2 3 EDINBURGH 4 1650 Abbott John A 1 - 0 Crichton Robert 1480 1655 Masters Andrew D 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1435 1475 Perry Jonathan 0 - 1 Havard Leonard 1480 0 Androvisaneas Elias 0 - 1 Cubitt David 1280 0 Wildberger A 0 - 1 Wilson David 1140 0 Tang Kai 1 - 0 Jones Robert M 1095 3 - 3 12 DRAGONS 4 3 EDINBURGH 4 1580 Porter William 0 - 1 Crichton Robert 1480 1485 Thomson Peter 0 - 1 Stuart Duncan 1435 Not Given A - H Havard Leonard 1480 Away Win by Default 1375 Hepburn James 0 - 1 Cubitt David 1280 1365 Harward Shaughan B 0 - 1 Wilson David 1140 1320 Duncan Brian 1 - 0 Orrell Mark 0 1 - 5 3 EDINBURGH 4 13 WESTER HAILE 1480 Crichton Robert 1 - 0 Williamson Keith 1360 1435 Stuart Duncan 0 - 1 MacKinney Stuart 1350 1480 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 Henderson Malcolm 1340 1280 Cubitt David 1 - 0 Ross Alexander 1335 1140 Wilson David 1 - 0 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 0 Graham James ½ - ½ Robertson Kenneth A 1255 3½ - 2½ 5 EDIN WEST 2 4 CIVIL SERV 2 1720 MacDonald Paul 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1765 1680 Walkingshaw Andrew D ½ - ½ Duckworth Peter 1540 1610 Benigan Austen ½ - ½ Anderson George C 1535 1565 Deas William B 0 - 1 Brown Gerry 1510 1515 Deas John 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1490 1480 Seywright Alan A 0 - 1 Kirk Steven 1375 1 - 5 4 CIVIL SERV 2 6 EW 3 1765 Austin Rudolf J ½ - ½ Redpath Joe 1485 1535 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Grant William M 1365 1510 Brown Gerry 1 - 0 Whalen Ron N 1345 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Young Stanley M 1260 1450 Jilow Asghar 1 - 0 Grant Iain C 1255 1160 Bridgeman Graham 1 - 0 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 5½ - ½ 4 CIVIL SERV 2 7 LASSWADE 2 1765 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1540 Duckworth Peter 0 - 1 Findlay Jack 1545 1535 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Keeley Gerald 1480 1510 Brown Gerry 1 - 0 Nisbet Charles 1405 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Campbell Ian 1345 1450 Jilow Asghar 1 - 0 Owens John 0 5 - 1 8 LIVINGSTON 4 CIVIL SERV 2 0 Blick Anthony 1 - 0 Austin Rudolf J 1765 1520 Gordon James K 1 - 0 Duckworth Peter 1540 1600 Thomson George ½ - ½ Anderson George C 1535 1480 Petch Rab ½ - ½ Brown Gerry 1510 1430 MacCord Robert 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1490 1320 Wright Paul 0 - 1 Jilow Asghar 1450 3 - 3 4 CIVIL SERV 2 9 MUSSELB 3 1765 Austin Rudolf J 0 - 1 MacFarlane Alex 1390 1540 Duckworth Peter 0 - 1 Colquhoun William 1265 1535 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Montgomery Jim 1240 1510 Brown Gerry 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1200 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1170 1450 Jilow Asghar 0 - 1 Knox David 955 3 - 3 4 CIVIL SERV 2 10 PENT HILLS 2 1765 Austin Rudolf J ½ - ½ Ewington Lenny C 1490 1540 Duckworth Peter ½ - ½ Ridland Lindsay S 1485 1535 Anderson George C ½ - ½ Fenoulhet Ray G 1350 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 MacFarlane George 1170 1450 Jilow Asghar 1 - 0 Ewington Bryan 1305 0 Mohammed Glen 1 - 0 Orr Jim 0 4½ - 1½ 4 CIVIL SERV 2 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1765 Austin Rudolf J ½ - ½ Sanchez Pablo 0 1540 Duckworth Peter 0 - 1 Chia Mark 0 1535 Anderson George C 0 - 1 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1510 Brown Gerry 1 - 0 Thompson John S 1595 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Arnone Silvio 1500 1450 Jilow Asghar ½ - ½ Chandra Anu 1260 3 - 3 4 CIVIL SERV 2 12 DRAGONS 4 1765 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Platts William G C 1650 1540 Duckworth Peter ½ - ½ Falconer William 1595 1535 Anderson George C ½ - ½ Porter William 1580 1510 Brown Gerry 0 - 1 Hepburn James 1375 1490 Miller Patrick M ½ - ½ Pirrie Gregor 1355 1370 Bate Simon 1 - 0 Duncan Brian 1320 3½ - 2½ 4 CIVIL SERV 2 13 WESTER HAILE 1765 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Williamson Keith 1360 1540 Duckworth Peter 1 - 0 Janek Paul 1380 1535 Anderson George C 1 - 0 MacKinney Stuart 1350 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Henderson Malcolm 1340 1450 Jilow Asghar 1 - 0 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 1375 Kirk Steven 0 - 1 Robertson Kenneth A 1255 5 - 1 6 EW 3 5 EDIN WEST 2 1485 Redpath Joe ½ - ½ Walkingshaw Andrew D 1680 1410 Russell Tom ½ - ½ Deas William B 1565 1400 Casey Brian 1 - 0 Deas John 1515 1365 Grant William M 1 - 0 Seywright Alan A 1480 1345 Whalen Ron N 1 - 0 Crosbie Stewart 0 1255 Grant Iain C 0 - 1 Sykes I 0 4 - 2 5 EDIN WEST 2 7 LASSWADE 2 1720 MacDonald Paul ½ - ½ Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1680 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1 - 0 Findlay Jack 1545 1610 Benigan Austen 1 - 0 Keeley Gerald 1480 1565 Deas William B 1 - 0 Nisbet Charles 1405 1515 Deas John 1 - 0 MacIntosh Alan 1395 1480 Seywright Alan A 0 - 1 Campbell Ian 1345 4½ - 1½ 5 EDIN WEST 2 8 LIVINGSTON 1720 MacDonald Paul 0 - 1 Blick Anthony 0 1610 Benigan Austen ½ - ½ Gordon James K 1520 1565 Deas William B 1 - 0 Thomson George 1600 1515 Deas John 0 - 1 Petch Rab 1480 1480 Seywright Alan A ½ - ½ MacCord Robert 1430 1400 Casey Brian ½ - ½ Wright Paul 1320 2½ - 3½ 9 MUSSELB 3 5 EDIN WEST 2 1390 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 MacDonald Paul 1720 1340 King David ½ - ½ Benigan Austen 1610 1265 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Deas William B 1565 1200 Hope Iain D 0 - 1 Deas John 1515 1170 Stokes Eddie 0 - 1 Seywright Alan A 1480 955 Knox David 1 - 0 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 1½ - 4½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 5 EDIN WEST 2 1490 Ewington Lenny C 0 - 1 Deas William B 1565 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 1 - 0 Deas John 1515 1350 Fenoulhet Ray G 1 - 0 Russell Tom 1410 1305 Ewington Bryan 1 - 0 Casey Brian 1400 1170 MacFarlane George 0 - 1 Whalen Ron N 1345 0 Orr Jim 1 - 0 Young Stanley M 1260 4 - 2 5 EDIN WEST 2 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1680 Walkingshaw Andrew D ½ - ½ Peddi N Choudary 1710 1565 Deas William B 0 - 1 Masters Andrew D 1655 1515 Deas John ½ - ½ Thompson John S 1595 1480 Seywright Alan A 1 - 0 Shapland D 1430 1410 Russell Tom ½ - ½ Chandra Anu 1260 1345 Whalen Ron N 1 - 0 Davies Paul 1240 3½ - 2½ 12 DRAGONS 4 5 EDIN WEST 2 1650 Platts William G C 1 - 0 MacDonald Paul 1720 1600 Binnie Scott 1 - 0 Benigan Austen 1610 1580 Porter William 0 - 1 Deas William B 1565 1375 Hepburn James 1 - 0 Seywright Alan A 1480 1355 Pirrie Gregor 0 - 1 Grant William M 1365 1320 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 Grant Iain C 1255 3 - 3 13 WESTER HAILE 5 EDIN WEST 2 1380 Janek Paul 0 - 1 MacDonald Paul 1720 1350 MacKinney Stuart 0 - 1 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1680 1335 Ross Alexander 0 - 1 Deas William B 1565 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 0 - 1 Deas John 1515 1270 Girdwood Paul 0 - 1 Seywright Alan A 1480 1220 Muirhead Ian 1 - 0 Russell Tom 1410 1 - 5 7 LASSWADE 2 6 EW 3 1605 Flockhart Hugh S 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1485 1545 Findlay Jack 1 - 0 Grant William M 1365 1480 Keeley Gerald 0 - 1 Whalen Ron N 1345 1405 Nisbet Charles 1 - 0 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 1345 Campbell Ian 0 - 1 Grant Iain C 1255 0 Owens John 1 - 0 Balfour John 1025 3 - 3 8 LIVINGSTON 6 EW 3 0 Blick Anthony ½ - ½ Redpath Joe 1485 1600 Thomson George ½ - ½ Russell Tom 1410 1520 Gordon James K ½ - ½ Grant William M 1365 1480 Petch Rab ½ - ½ Whalen Ron N 1345 1430 MacCord Robert 1 - 0 Grant Iain C 1255 0 Wright Andrew 1 - 0 Glynn M Ivor 1140 4 - 2 6 EW 3 9 MUSSELB 3 1485 Redpath Joe 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1390 1365 Grant William M ½ - ½ Colquhoun William 1265 1345 Whalen Ron N 1 - 0 Montgomery Jim 1240 1325 Dunnett Andrew W 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1200 1265 Dunnett Stuart W 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1170 1255 Grant Iain C 0 - 1 Knox David 955 3½ - 2½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 6 EW 3 1490 Ewington Lenny C 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1485 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 0 - 1 Grant William M 1365 1305 Ewington Bryan 1 - 0 Whalen Ron N 1345 1170 MacFarlane George 0 - 1 Dunnett Andrew W 1325 0 Orr Jim 0 - 1 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 0 Stewart John N S 0 - 1 Grant Iain C 1255 1 - 5 6 EW 3 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1485 Redpath Joe 1 - 0 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1365 Grant William M 0 - 1 Masters Andrew D 1655 1345 Whalen Ron N 0 - 1 Arnone Silvio 1500 1265 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Chandra Anu 1260 1260 Young Stanley M 1 - 0 Osbourne Martin 0 1255 Grant Iain C H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 3 - 3 6 EW 3 12 DRAGONS 4 1485 Redpath Joe 0 - 1 Falconer William 1595 1410 Russell Tom 0 - 1 Porter William 1580 1400 Casey Brian ½ - ½ Hepburn James 1375 1365 Grant William M 1 - 0 Harward Shaughan B 1365 1345 Whalen Ron N 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1355 1265 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Duncan Brian 1320 1½ - 4½ 13 WESTER HAILE 6 EW 3 1360 Williamson Keith 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1485 1380 Janek Paul ½ - ½ Russell Tom 1410 1350 MacKinney Stuart 1 - 0 Woodhead David 1390 1335 Ross Alexander 0 - 1 Grant William M 1365 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 0 - 1 Whalen Ron N 1345 1255 Robertson Kenneth A ½ - ½ Dunnett Stuart W 1265 2 - 4 8 LIVINGSTON 7 LASSWADE 2 0 Blick Anthony ½ - ½ Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1520 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Findlay Jack 1545 1600 Thomson George 1 - 0 Keeley Gerald 1480 1480 Petch Rab 0 - 1 Nisbet Charles 1405 1430 MacCord Robert 0 - 1 Campbell Ian 1345 0 Wright Andrew ½ - ½ Owens John 0 2 - 4 7 LASSWADE 2 9 MUSSELB 3 1605 Flockhart Hugh S 1 - 0 King David 1340 1545 Findlay Jack 1 - 0 Colquhoun William 1265 1480 Keeley Gerald 0 - 1 Montgomery Jim 1240 1405 Nisbet Charles ½ - ½ Hope Iain D 1200 1345 Campbell Ian 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1170 0 Owens John 1 - 0 Knox David 955 4½ - 1½ 7 LASSWADE 2 10 PENT HILLS 2 1605 Flockhart Hugh S ½ - ½ Ewington Lenny C 1490 1545 Findlay Jack 0 - 1 Ewington Bryan 1305 1480 Keeley Gerald 1 - 0 MacFarlane George 1170 1405 Nisbet Charles 1 - 0 Davies-Cole Charles 810 1345 Campbell Ian 1 - 0 Orr Jim 0 1090 Middleton Peter D 1 - 0 Stewart John N S 0 4½ - 1½ 2 CORSTORPHINE 1 BANK OF SCOT 1515 Dowling Richard K 0 - 1 Kilgour James W 1475 1515 Elders Peter 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1380 1505 Burns David ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1315 1385 Douglas Alexander G ½ - ½ Murray Robin H 1270 1360 Gilbert Harry ½ - ½ Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 1350 MacKay Roddy J 1 - 0 Melvin James 980 3½ - 2½ 1 BANK OF SCOT 3 EDINBURGH 4 1380 Murray Findlay R 1 - 0 Crichton Robert 1480 1315 Ferrie Louis C 1 - 0 Stuart Duncan 1435 1290 Goldie Martin 0 - 1 Havard Leonard 1480 1270 Murray Robin H 1 - 0 Murphy George A A 0 1085 Main Ken 0 - 1 Cubitt David 1280 980 Melvin James 1 - 0 Graham James 0 4 - 2 4 CIVIL SERV 2 1 BANK OF SCOT 1765 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Ferrie Louis C 1315 1540 Duckworth Peter 1 - 0 Goldie Martin 1290 1535 Anderson George C 1 - 0 Murray Robin H 1270 1490 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 1450 Jilow Asghar 1 - 0 Main Ken 1085 1375 Kirk Steven 1 - 0 Edwards Colin 0 6 - 0 5 EDIN WEST 2 1 BANK OF SCOT 1680 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1 - 0 Kilgour James W 1475 1565 Deas William B 0 - 1 Murray Findlay R 1380 1515 Deas John 1 - 0 Ferrie Louis C 1315 1480 Seywright Alan A 1 - 0 Murray Robin H 1270 1410 Russell Tom 1 - 0 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 0 Crosbie Stewart 0 - 1 Melvin James 980 4 - 2 6 EW 3 1 BANK OF SCOT 1485 Redpath Joe 1 - 0 Kilgour James W 1475 1365 Grant William M H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1345 Whalen Ron N ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1315 1265 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Colledge John B 1275 1260 Young Stanley M 1 - 0 Main Ken 1085 1255 Grant Iain C 1 - 0 Melvin James 980 4½ - 1½ 1 BANK OF SCOT 7 LASSWADE 2 1380 Murray Findlay R 0 - 1 Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1315 Ferrie Louis C 0 - 1 Findlay Jack 1545 1290 Goldie Martin 0 - 1 Hutchison John 1520 1270 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Keeley Gerald 1480 1085 Main Ken 0 - 1 Campbell Ian 1345 980 Melvin James 0 - 1 Owens John 0 0 - 6 1 BANK OF SCOT 8 LIVINGSTON 1380 Murray Findlay R ½ - ½ Blick Anthony 0 1370 Davidson John F 1 - 0 Gordon James K 1520 1315 Ferrie Louis C 0 - 1 Petch Rab 1480 1250 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 0 - 1 MacCord Robert 1430 1085 Main Ken 0 - 1 Wright Paul 1320 980 Melvin James 0 - 1 Wright Andrew 0 1½ - 4½ 9 MUSSELB 3 1 BANK OF SCOT 1390 MacFarlane Alex 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1380 1340 King David ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1315 1265 Colquhoun William 1 - 0 Main Ken 1085 1240 Montgomery Jim ½ - ½ Melvin James 980 1200 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Edwards Colin 0 955 Knox David H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 5 - 1 1 BANK OF SCOT 10 PENT HILLS 2 1475 MacVey Ernie 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1490 1380 Murray Findlay R ½ - ½ Ridland Lindsay S 1485 1315 Ferrie Louis C ½ - ½ Fenoulhet Ray G 1350 1270 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Ewington Bryan 1305 1250 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1 - 0 MacFarlane George 1170 980 Melvin James 1 - 0 Orr Jim 0 3 - 3 1 BANK OF SCOT 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1475 Kilgour James W ½ - ½ Sanchez Pablo 0 1380 Murray Findlay R 0 - 1 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1315 Ferrie Louis C 0 - 1 Chia Mark 0 1270 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Abbott John A 1650 1250 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 0 - 1 Arnone Silvio 1500 980 Melvin James 0 - 1 Perry Jonathan 1475 ½ - 5½ 12 DRAGONS 4 1 BANK OF SCOT 1650 Platts William G C 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1380 1600 Binnie Scott 1 - 0 Murray Robin H 1270 1595 Falconer William 1 - 0 Kilgour James W 1475 1580 Porter William H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1375 Hepburn James 1 - 0 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 1355 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 Melvin James 980 6 - 0 13 WESTER HAILE 1 BANK OF SCOT 1360 Williamson Keith 0 - 1 Kilgour James W 1475 1380 Janek Paul 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1380 1350 MacKinney Stuart 1 - 0 Ferrie Louis C 1315 1335 Ross Alexander 1 - 0 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 1 - 0 Main Ken 1085 1270 Girdwood Paul 0 - 1 Melvin James 980 4 - 2 2 CORSTORPHINE 3 EDINBURGH 4 1515 Dowling Richard K 0 - 1 Crichton Robert 1480 1515 Elders Peter 0 - 1 Stuart Duncan 1435 1505 Burns David 1 - 0 Havard Leonard 1480 1325 Bates Joe 1 - 0 Cubitt David 1280 1360 Gilbert Harry ½ - ½ Graham James 0 Not Given H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 3½ - 2½ 2 CORSTORPHINE 4 CIVIL SERV 2 1515 Dowling Richard K 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1765 1515 Elders Peter 0 - 1 Duckworth Peter 1540 1505 Burns David 0 - 1 Anderson George C 1535 1325 Bates Joe 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1490 1360 Gilbert Harry 0 - 1 Jilow Asghar 1450 1350 MacKay Roddy J 1 - 0 Kirk Steven 1375 1 - 5 2 CORSTORPHINE 5 EDIN WEST 2 1515 Elders Peter ½ - ½ Walkingshaw Andrew D 1680 1515 Dowling Richard K ½ - ½ Benigan Austen 1610 1505 Burns David ½ - ½ Deas William B 1565 1360 Gilbert Harry ½ - ½ Deas John 1515 1350 MacKay Roddy J 0 - 1 Seywright Alan A 1480 1325 Bates Joe 1 - 0 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 3 - 3 6 EW 3 2 CORSTORPHINE 1485 Redpath Joe 1 - 0 Elders Peter 1515 1365 Grant William M 0 - 1 Dowling Richard K 1515 1345 Whalen Ron N 1 - 0 Burns David 1505 1265 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Bates Joe 1325 1260 Young Stanley M 1 - 0 Gilbert Harry 1360 1255 Grant Iain C ½ - ½ MacKay Roddy J 1350 3½ - 2½ 7 LASSWADE 2 2 CORSTORPHINE 1605 Flockhart Hugh S 1 - 0 Elders Peter 1515 1545 Findlay Jack 1 - 0 Burns David 1505 1480 Keeley Gerald ½ - ½ Dowling Richard K 1515 1405 Nisbet Charles 1 - 0 Gilbert Harry 1360 1395 MacIntosh Alan 0 - 1 MacKay Roddy J 1350 1345 Campbell Ian 0 - 1 Bates Joe 1325 3½ - 2½ 2 CORSTORPHINE 8 LIVINGSTON 1515 Dowling Richard K 0 - 1 Blick Anthony 0 1515 Elders Peter ½ - ½ Thomson George 1600 1505 Burns David 0 - 1 Petch Rab 1480 1325 Bates Joe 0 - 1 MacCord Robert 1430 1350 MacKay Roddy J ½ - ½ Wright Paul 1320 0 King David 0 - 1 MacGilvary Dave 0 1 - 5 9 MUSSELB 3 2 CORSTORPHINE 1390 MacFarlane Alex ½ - ½ Elders Peter 1515 1340 King David 0 - 1 Dowling Richard K 1515 1265 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Burns David 1505 1240 Montgomery Jim ½ - ½ Bates Joe 1325 1170 Stokes Eddie ½ - ½ Gilbert Harry 1360 955 Knox David 1 - 0 MacKay Roddy J 1350 2½ - 3½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 2 CORSTORPHINE 1490 Ewington Lenny C 0 - 1 Dowling Richard K 1515 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 0 - 1 Elders Peter 1515 1305 Ewington Bryan ½ - ½ Burns David 1505 1170 MacFarlane George 0 - 1 Gilbert Harry 1360 810 Davies-Cole Charles 0 - 1 Bates Joe 1325 1350 Fenoulhet Ray G 0 - 1 Crerar Bruce 950 ½ - 5½ 2 CORSTORPHINE 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1515 Elders Peter 0 - 1 Sanchez Pablo 0 1515 Dowling Richard K 0 - 1 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1505 Burns David 0 - 1 Masters Andrew D 1655 1325 Bates Joe ½ - ½ Arnone Silvio 1500 1360 Gilbert Harry 0 - 1 Vogt Martin 0 1350 MacKay Roddy J 1 - 0 Androvisaneas Elias 0 1½ - 4½ 12 DRAGONS 4 2 CORSTORPHINE 1595 Falconer William 1 - 0 Elders Peter 1515 1580 Porter William 0 - 1 Dowling Richard K 1515 1375 Hepburn James 1 - 0 Bates Joe 1325 1355 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 MacKay Roddy J 1350 1365 Harward Shaughan B ½ - ½ Gourlay Brian 1330 1320 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 Ruthven Angus G 1265 3½ - 2½ 13 WESTER HAILE 2 CORSTORPHINE 1360 Williamson Keith 0 - 1 Dowling Richard K 1515 1350 MacKinney Stuart 0 - 1 Elders Peter 1515 1335 Ross Alexander 0 - 1 Burns David 1505 1340 Henderson Malcolm 0 - 1 Bates Joe 1325 1270 Girdwood Paul 1 - 0 Ruthven Angus G 1265 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 0 - 1 Crerar Bruce 950 1 - 5 3 EDINBURGH 4 4 CIVIL SERV 2 1480 Crichton Robert 0 - 1 Anderson George C 1535 1435 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Brown Gerry 1510 1480 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 Miller Patrick M 1490 1280 Cubitt David 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 0 1110 Costello John 0 - 1 Bate Simon 1370 0 Graham James 0 - 1 Powell Alex 1230 2 - 4 5 EDIN WEST 2 3 EDINBURGH 4 1680 Walkingshaw Andrew D ½ - ½ Lopez-Saldana Alejan 1615 1565 Deas William B ½ - ½ Crichton Robert 1480 1515 Deas John ½ - ½ Stuart Duncan 1435 Not Given A - H Havard Leonard 1480 Away Win by Default 1410 Russell Tom ½ - ½ Cubitt David 1280 1255 Grant Iain C 0 - 1 Jones Robert M 1095 2 - 4 3 EDINBURGH 4 6 EW 3 1435 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Redpath Joe 1485 1480 Havard Leonard H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1280 Cubitt David 1 - 0 Woodhead David 1390 1140 Wilson David 1 - 0 Grant William M 1365 1110 Costello John 0 - 1 Whalen Ron N 1345 0 Graham James 1 - 0 Grant Iain C 1255 5 - 1 3 EDINBURGH 4 7 LASSWADE 2 1480 Havard Leonard 0 - 1 Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1435 Stuart Duncan ½ - ½ Findlay Jack 1545 1280 Cubitt David 1 - 0 Nisbet Charles 1405 1140 Wilson David ½ - ½ Campbell Ian 1345 1110 Costello John 0 - 1 Owens John 0 0 Graham James 1 - 0 Middleton Peter D 1090 3 - 3 3 EDINBURGH 4 8 LIVINGSTON 1615 Lopez-Saldana Alejan 1 - 0 Blick Anthony 0 1435 Stuart Duncan 0 - 1 Thomson George 1600 1480 Havard Leonard ½ - ½ Petch Rab 1480 0 Murphy George A A 1 - 0 MacCord Robert 1430 1280 Cubitt David ½ - ½ Wright Paul 1320 1140 Wilson David 1 - 0 MacGilvary Dave 0 4 - 2 9 MUSSELB 3 3 EDINBURGH 4 1390 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 Crichton Robert 1480 1265 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Stuart Duncan 1435 1240 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Havard Leonard 1480 1200 Hope Iain D 0 - 1 Murphy George A A 0 1170 Stokes Eddie 0 - 1 Cubitt David 1280 955 Knox David 1 - 0 Jones Robert M 1095 1 - 5 3 EDINBURGH 4 10 PENT HILLS 2 1480 Crichton Robert 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1490 1435 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Ridland Lindsay S 1485 1480 Havard Leonard 1 - 0 Fenoulhet Ray G 1350 1280 Cubitt David 0 - 1 Ewington Bryan 1305 1140 Wilson David 1 - 0 MacFarlane George 1170 1110 Costello John 1 - 0 Stewart John N S 0 4 - 2 11 EDIN UNIV 2 7 LASSWADE 2 1710 Peddi N Choudary 1 - 0 Flockhart Hugh S 1605 1655 Masters Andrew D 1 - 0 Keeley Gerald 1480 1650 Abbott John A 1 - 0 Nisbet Charles 1405 1595 Thompson John S 1 - 0 Owens John 0 1260 Chandra Anu 1 - 0 Middleton Peter D 1090 0 Osbourne Martin 1 - 0 Franks Tom 0 6 - 0 7 LASSWADE 2 12 DRAGONS 4 1605 Flockhart Hugh S ½ - ½ Platts William G C 1650 1545 Findlay Jack 1 - 0 Binnie Scott 1600 1480 Keeley Gerald 0 - 1 Falconer William 1595 1405 Nisbet Charles 1 - 0 Hepburn James 1375 1345 Campbell Ian 1 - 0 Pirrie Gregor 1355 0 Owens John 1 - 0 Duncan Brian 1320 4½ - 1½ 7 LASSWADE 2 13 WESTER HAILE 1605 Flockhart Hugh S ½ - ½ Williamson Keith 1360 1545 Findlay Jack 1 - 0 Janek Paul 1380 1345 Campbell Ian 1 - 0 MacKinney Stuart 1350 0 Owens John 1 - 0 Ross Alexander 1335 1090 Middleton Peter D 0 - 1 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 960 Paxton Alex 0 - 1 Muirhead Ian 1220 3½ - 2½ 9 MUSSELB 3 8 LIVINGSTON 1390 MacFarlane Alex ½ - ½ Gordon James K 1520 1340 King David ½ - ½ Thomson George 1600 1240 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Petch Rab 1480 1200 Hope Iain D ½ - ½ MacCord Robert 1430 1170 Stokes Eddie ½ - ½ Wright Andrew 0 955 Knox David 0 - 1 MacGilvary Dave 0 2 - 4 8 LIVINGSTON 10 PENT HILLS 2 0 Blick Anthony 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1490 1520 Gordon James K 0 - 1 Ridland Lindsay S 1485 1600 Thomson George 1 - 0 Ewington Bryan 1305 1430 MacCord Robert 1 - 0 MacFarlane George 1170 0 Wright Andrew 1 - 0 Orr Jim 0 1320 Wright Paul H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 4 - 2 8 LIVINGSTON 11 EDIN UNIV 2 0 Blick Anthony 0 - 1 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1600 Thomson George 0 - 1 Masters Andrew D 1655 1520 Gordon James K 1 - 0 Abbott John A 1650 1430 MacCord Robert 1 - 0 Vogt Martin 0 1030 Kellock Ian 0 - 1 Tang Kai 0 Not Given A - H Not Given Away Win by Default 2 - 4 8 LIVINGSTON 12 DRAGONS 4 0 Blick Anthony ½ - ½ Platts William G C 1650 1600 Thomson George ½ - ½ Falconer William 1595 1520 Gordon James K 1 - 0 Porter William 1580 1480 Petch Rab 1 - 0 Hepburn James 1375 1430 MacCord Robert ½ - ½ Pirrie Gregor 1355 1320 Wright Paul ½ - ½ Duncan Brian 1320 4 - 2 8 LIVINGSTON 13 WESTER HAILE 0 Blick Anthony ½ - ½ Williamson Keith 1360 1600 Thomson George 0 - 1 Janek Paul 1380 1520 Gordon James K 1 - 0 Henderson Malcolm 1340 1480 Petch Rab H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1430 MacCord Robert 1 - 0 Ross Alexander 1335 0 Wright Andrew 0 - 1 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 3½ - 2½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 9 MUSSELB 3 1490 Ewington Lenny C 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1390 Not Given H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 1 - 0 Colquhoun William 1265 1305 Ewington Bryan 1 - 0 Montgomery Jim 1240 1170 MacFarlane George 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1200 0 Orr Jim 0 - 1 Knox David 955 4 - 2 9 MUSSELB 3 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1390 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 Abbott John A 1650 1340 King David ½ - ½ Masters Andrew D 1655 1265 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Arnone Silvio 1500 1240 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Perry Jonathan 1475 1200 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Tang Kai 0 1170 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Osbourne Martin 0 2½ - 3½ 12 DRAGONS 4 9 MUSSELB 3 1650 Platts William G C 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1390 1595 Falconer William 1 - 0 King David 1340 1580 Porter William 1 - 0 Colquhoun William 1265 1375 Hepburn James 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1200 1365 Harward Shaughan B 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1170 1320 Duncan Brian 1 - 0 Knox David 955 6 - 0 13 WESTER HAILE 9 MUSSELB 3 1360 Williamson Keith 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1390 Not Given H - A Not Given Home Win by Default Not Given H - A Not Given Home Win by Default 1335 Ross Alexander 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1170 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1200 1220 Muirhead Ian 1 - 0 Knox David 955 6 - 0 11 EDIN UNIV 2 10 PENT HILLS 2 *** A Away Win By Default *** 0 - 6 10 PENT HILLS 2 12 DRAGONS 4 1490 Ewington Lenny C ½ - ½ Platts William G C 1650 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 1 - 0 Falconer William 1595 1350 Fenoulhet Ray G 0 - 1 Porter William 1580 1305 Ewington Bryan ½ - ½ Hepburn James 1375 1170 MacFarlane George 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1355 0 Orr Jim ½ - ½ Duncan Brian 1320 2½ - 3½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 13 WESTER HAILE 1490 Ewington Lenny C 1 - 0 Williamson Keith 1360 1485 Ridland Lindsay S 1 - 0 MacKinney Stuart 1350 1305 Ewington Bryan 1 - 0 Tait Chris T 1345 1170 MacFarlane George 1 - 0 Ross Alexander 1335 0 Orr Jim 1 - 0 Girdwood Paul 1270 0 Stewart John N S 0 - 1 Robertson Kenneth A 1255 5 - 1 12 DRAGONS 4 11 EDIN UNIV 2 1650 Platts William G C 1 - 0 Peddi N Choudary 1710 1595 Falconer William 0 - 1 Abbott John A 1650 1580 Porter William 0 - 1 Masters Andrew D 1655 1375 Hepburn James ½ - ½ Arnone Silvio 1500 1355 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 Perry Jonathan 1475 1320 Duncan Brian 1 - 0 Vogt Martin 0 3½ - 2½ 11 EDIN UNIV 2 13 WESTER HAILE 1710 Peddi N Choudary 1 - 0 Williamson Keith 1360 1655 Masters Andrew D 1 - 0 Janek Paul 1380 1500 Arnone Silvio ½ - ½ MacKinney Stuart 1350 1475 Perry Jonathan 1 - 0 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 0 Vogt Martin 0 - 1 Muirhead Ian 1220 Not Given A - H Not Given Away Win by Default 3½ - 2½ 13 WESTER HAILE 12 DRAGONS 4 1360 Williamson Keith 0 - 1 Binnie Scott 1600 1350 MacKinney Stuart ½ - ½ Falconer William 1595 1345 Tait Chris T 0 - 1 Hepburn James 1375 1340 Henderson Malcolm 1 - 0 Harward Shaughan B 1365 1335 Ross Alexander 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1355 1310 MacIntosh Sally A 1 - 0 Duncan Brian 1320 2½ - 3½
Table Order 3D M pts ----------Boards (6 per Match)-------- ----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score- Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds % 1 4 CIVIL SERV 2 12 9 0 3 21 46 13 13 0 0 0 52½ 73 2 8 LIVINGSTON 12 8 3 1 17 27 17 25 2 1 0 41½ 58 3 3 EDINBURGH 4 12 7 3 2 16 35 23 10 3 1 0 43 60 4 7 LASSWADE 2 12 7 3 2 16 34 28 10 0 0 0 39 54 5 11 EDIN UNIV 2 12 6 3 3 15 35 18 10 1 8 0 41 57 6 12 DRAGONS 4 12 7 4 1 15 32 23 15 1 1 0 40½ 56 7 6 EW 3 12 6 4 2 14 27 29 13 2 1 0 35½ 49 8 5 EDIN WEST 2 12 5 5 2 12 27 24 20 0 1 0 37 51 9 2 CORSTORPHINE 12 5 6 1 11 25 28 18 1 0 0 35 49 10 10 PENT HILLS 2 12 4 7 1 9 21 33 10 7 1 0 33 46 11 13 WESTER HAILE 12 2 10 0 4 22 39 7 3 1 0 28½ 40 12 9 MUSSELB 3 12 1 10 1 3 16 39 13 1 3 0 23½ 33 13 1 BANK OF SCOT 12 1 10 1 3 13 46 10 0 3 0 18 25 -- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---- Tots for x-check 156 68 68 20 156 360 360 174 21 21 0 468
Match Cross Table 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Pld Pts 1 BANK OF SCOT x 2½ 4 0 2 1½ 0 1½ 1 3 ½ 0 2 72 18 2 CORSTORPHINE 3½ x 3½ 1 3 2½ 2½ 1 3½ 5½ 1½ 2½ 5 72 35 3 EDINBURGH 4 2 2½ x 2 4 5 3 4 5 4 3 5 3½ 72 43 4 CIVIL SERV 2 6 5 4 x 5 5½ 5 3 3 4½ 3 3½ 5 72 52½ 5 EDIN WEST 2 4 3 2 1 x 2 4½ 2½ 4½ 2 3½ 3 5 72 37 6 EW 3 4½ 3½ 1 ½ 4 x 3 2 3½ 5 3 1½ 4 72 35½ 7 LASSWADE 2 6 3½ 3 1 1½ 3 x 4 4½ 4½ 0 4½ 3½ 72 39 8 LIVINGSTON 4½ 5 2 3 3½ 4 2 x 4 4 2 4 3½ 72 41½ 9 MUSSELB 3 5 2½ 1 3 1½ 2½ 1½ 2 x 2 2½ 0 0 72 23½ 10 PENT HILLS 2 3 ½ 2 1½ 4 1 1½ 2 4 x 6 2½ 5 72 33 11 EDIN UNIV 2 5½ 4½ 3 3 2½ 3 6 4 3½ 0 x 2½ 3½ 72 41 12 DRAGONS 4 6 3½ 1 2½ 3 4½ 1½ 2 6 3½ 3½ x 3½ 72 40½ 13 WESTER HAILE 4 1 2½ 1 1 2 2½ 2½ 6 1 2½ 2½ x 72 28½
Individual Results *** Team 1 BANK OF SCOT *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 7025 Kilgour James W 1475 BS 6 2½ 6910 Murray Findlay R 1380 BS 10 3 3909 Ferrie Louis C 1315 BS 11 3 5442 Murray Robin H 1270 BS 8 1½ 7947 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1250 BS 8 1½ 11147 Melvin James 980 NEW BS 11 4½ 7023 Goldie Martin 1290 BS 3 0 4836 Main Ken 1085 BS 7 0 9836 Edwards Colin 0 BS 2 0 3556 Colledge John B 1275 BS 1 1 3683 Davidson John F 1370 BS 1 1 5234 MacVey Ernie 1475 BSRB 1 0 *** Team 2 CORSTORPHINE *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 3785 Dowling Richard K 1515 CO 12 6 3842 Elders Peter 1515 CO 12 4½ 3354 Burns David 1505 CO 11 4½ 3782 Douglas Alexander G 1385 CO 1 ½ 4070 Gilbert Harry 1360 CO 9 3 5114 MacKay Roddy J 1350 DLCO 9 5 8391 Bates Joe 1325 CO 11 7 12404 King David 0 CO 1 0 10620 Crerar Bruce 950 NEW CO 2 2 8390 Gourlay Brian 1330 CO 1 ½ 5883 Ruthven Angus G 1265 COGS 2 1 *** Team 3 EDINBURGH 4 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 3635 Crichton Robert 1480 ED 9 4½ 10514 Stuart Duncan 1435 ED 12 7 8057 Havard Leonard 1480 NEW ED 12 7½ 12163 Murphy George A A 0 ED 3 2 3648 Cubitt David 1280 ED 12 9 12440 Graham James 0 ED 6 3 8006 Costello John 1110 ED 4 1 9947 Lopez-Saldana Alejandro 1615 ED 2 1½ 4509 Jones Robert M 1095 ED 3 1 10184 Wilson David 1140 NEW ED 7 6½ 12247 Orrell Mark 0 ED 1 0 *** Team 4 CIVIL SERV 2 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 3084 Austin Rudolf J 1765 EDCS 11 7½ 3798 Duckworth Peter 1540 CS 10 4½ 3046 Anderson George C 1535 CS 12 9 5270 Miller Patrick M 1490 CS 12 11½ 8246 Jilow Asghar 1450 CS 9 7½ 4609 Kirk Steven 1375 CSMU 4 2 7921 Brown Gerry 1510 CS 8 5½ 9033 Bridgeman Graham 1160 CS 1 1 12392 Mohammed Glen 0 CS 1 1 3143 Bate Simon 1370 CS 2 2 11978 Jackson Ralph 0 CS 1 0 5672 Powell Alex 1230 CS 1 1 *** Team 5 EDIN WEST 2 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 7993 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1680 J16 EW 8 5½ 3705 Deas William B 1565 EW 12 7½ 3703 Deas John 1515 EW 11 5½ 5943 Seywright Alan A 1480 EWCC 10 5½ 5879 Russell Tom 1410 SO 5 2 12423 Crosbie Stewart 0 EW 2 0 3178 Benigan Austen 1610 EWKN 6 3 7926 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 EW 2 0 4167 Grant Iain C 1255 EW 2 1 11408 MacDonald Paul 1720 NEW EWEU 6 2½ 8350 Redpath Joe 1485 J11 EW 0 0 3462 Casey Brian 1400 LSEW 2 ½ 4174 Grant William M 1365 EW 1 1 6443 Whalen Ron N 1345 EW 2 2 6573 Young Stanley M 1260 EW 1 0 12443 Sykes I 0 EW 1 1 *** Team 6 EW 3 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 8350 Redpath Joe 1485 J11 EW 12 8½ 4174 Grant William M 1365 EW 12 6 6443 Whalen Ron N 1345 EW 12 7 7926 Dunnett Stuart W 1265 EW 9 2½ 6573 Young Stanley M 1260 EW 4 3 4167 Grant Iain C 1255 EW 10 4½ 9527 Woodhead David 1390 EW 2 0 5879 Russell Tom 1410 SO 4 1½ 3462 Casey Brian 1400 LSEW 2 1½ 3103 Balfour John 1025 EW 1 0 4105 Glynn M Ivor 1140 EW 1 0 7925 Dunnett Andrew W 1325 J18 EW 2 1 *** Team 7 LASSWADE 2 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 3950 Flockhart Hugh S 1605 LS 12 6½ 9508 Findlay Jack 1545 LS 11 8½ 4437 Hutchison John 1520 LS 1 1 4529 Keeley Gerald 1480 LS 10 2½ 10507 Campbell Ian 1345 LS 11 7½ 11832 Owens John 0 LS 9 6½ 10970 Nisbet Charles 1405 NEW LS 10 5½ 5092 MacIntosh Alan 1395 LS 2 0 5254 Middleton Peter D 1090 LS 4 1 10972 Franks Tom 0 LS 1 0 8664 Paxton Alex 960 J14 LS 1 0 *** Team 8 LIVINGSTON *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 11588 Blick Anthony 0 LV 11 5½ 4127 Gordon James K 1520 LV 10 5½ 5621 Petch Rab 1480 LV 10 7½ 4979 MacCord Robert 1430 LV 12 7½ 9587 Wright Paul 1320 J17 BKJY 7 4 11834 Wright Andrew 0 LV 6 4 10598 Thomson George 1600 LV 11 5½ 12405 MacGilvary Dave 0 LV 3 2 11302 Kellock Ian 1030 NEW LV 1 0 *** Team 9 MUSSELB 3 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 9511 MacFarlane Alex 1390 MU 11 3 4596 King David 1340 MU 7 2 9509 Colquhoun William 1265 MU 10 2½ 5330 Montgomery Jim 1240 MU 9 2 4379 Hope Iain D 1200 MU 11 5 11599 Knox David 955 NEW PLMU 11 7 6140 Stokes Eddie 1170 MU 10 2 *** Team 10 PENT HILLS 2 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 3865 Ewington Lenny C 1490 PH 11 6½ 7097 Ridland Lindsay S 1485 PH 10 6 3891 Fenoulhet Ray G 1350 PH 6 2 3864 Ewington Bryan 1305 J19 PH 11 8 4771 MacFarlane George 1170 STPH 11 1 11542 Orr Jim 0 PH 9 2½ 10178 Davies-Cole Charles 810 PH 2 0 12383 Stewart John N S 0 PH 4 0 *** Team 11 EDIN UNIV 2 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 12216 Sanchez Pablo 0 EU 3 2 7721 Peddi N Choudary 1710 EU 9 6½ 12217 Chia Mark 0 EU 2 2 3001 Abbott John A 1650 OBLS 6 5 11351 Arnone Silvio 1500 NEW EU 7 4½ 11413 Perry Jonathan 1475 NEW EU 5 3 10382 Masters Andrew D 1655 J20 EU 9 8½ 12410 Vogt Martin 0 EU 4 1 12437 Androvisaneas Elias 0 EU 2 0 12434 Wildberger A 0 EU 1 0 12438 Tang Kai 0 EU 3 2 11078 Chandra Anu 1260 EU 4 3 12439 Shapland D 1430 EU 1 0 10785 Davies Paul 1240 NEW EU 1 0 11729 Osbourne Martin 0 EU 3 1 6228 Thompson John S 1595 EU 3 1½ *** Team 12 DRAGONS 4 *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 5650 Platts William G C 1650 STDB 8 5½ 3198 Binnie Scott 1600 J19 GRWD 4 3 3872 Falconer William 1595 WD 10 6½ 5666 Porter William 1580 WD 10 4½ 9041 Hepburn James 1375 WD 12 7½ 5643 Pirrie Gregor 1355 WH 10 7 4294 Harward Shaughan B 1365 EDWD 5 1½ 9578 Duncan Brian 1320 SBWD 11 5 6254 Thomson Peter 1485 WD 1 0 *** Team 13 WESTER HAILE *** PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points 8924 Williamson Keith 1360 J12 BUWH 11 2 10781 Janek Paul 1380 NEW WH 7 2½ 5147 MacKinney Stuart 1350 WH 10 4 7791 Ross Alexander 1335 J13 WH 10 2 7712 MacIntosh Sally A 1310 WH 11 5 11503 Girdwood Paul 1270 NEW WH 4 1 4324 Henderson Malcolm 1340 WH 5 2 5817 Robertson Kenneth A 1255 WH 4 3 6628 Muirhead Ian 1220 WH 4 4 7575 Tait Chris T 1345 WH 2 0
[past league results index] [96/97 results]
[Edinburgh University Chess Club Home Page]